In this episode of Medical Mentor Coaching, Dr. Stacey Ishman unpacks why being the most reliable faculty member can quietly stall your academic career. She introduces opportunity selection as a critical (and teachable) career skill, explaining how saying yes to the wrong work—even when it’s valued and appreciated—can slow promotion, visibility, and leadership advancement for physicians in their first 10 years of practice.

No need to take notes—check out the blog for a written summary of these insights.

If you are interested in learning how to build a promotion-ready career strategy instead of defaulting into overcommitment, this episode will help you rethink how and when to say yes.

Key Points:

1. Why the Most Reliable Faculty Get Stuck (0:00 – 2:10)
How dependable, high-performing physicians often feel invisible despite being indispensable
Why this stagnation is often misdiagnosed as burnout
The hidden cost of doing essential but non-advancing work

2. The Real Problem Isn’t Effort—It’s Selection (2:10 – 4:00)
Why productivity, resilience, and motivation aren’t the issue
How academic medicine trains execution but not decision-making
The long-term consequences of default yeses

3. Promotion Is About Narrative, Not Effort (4:00 – 5:45)
How promotion committees evaluate coherence, trajectory, and impact
Why scattered service roles dilute your story
The difference between being busy and being promotable

4. The Trade-Off Between Being Helpful and Being Strategic (5:45 – 7:10)
Why saying yes feels professional—and why that can be misleading
How loyalty and guilt influence opportunity decisions
When service helps your career and when it quietly hurts it

5. Opportunity Selection as a Career Skill (7:10 – 8:50)
Why saying no is disciplined, not selfish
How intentional yeses build depth, visibility, and authority
How to redirect opportunities toward roles that fit your goals

6. A Real Coaching Case: Invisible Work, Missed Advancement (8:50 – 10:20)
A mid-career faculty example of being passed over for leadership
Why invisible institutional work doesn’t translate externally
How redesigning roles and focus changes outcomes

7. What Leaders Miss—and Why Retention Suffers (10:20 – 11:40)
How departments unintentionally overload their most reliable faculty
Why departures often feel sudden but are actually predictable
How strategic opportunity alignment can prevent attrition

8. Practical Questions Before You Say Yes (11:40 – 12:50)
What this opportunity replaces
How it maps to promotion criteria and skill-building
Whether it advances your next step—or is time to let it go

9. From Silent Overcommitment to Strategic Careers (12:50 – 14:10)
Why goodwill sustains departments but strategy drives promotion
How opportunity selection benefits both faculty and institutions
Making intentional career design part of academic culture

Summary

Academic medicine runs on reliable faculty—but careers advance through intentional strategy. In this episode, Dr. Ishman reframes saying yes as a choice that shapes your professional narrative, not a measure of commitment. By learning how to select opportunities that align with promotion criteria, leadership goals, and long-term impact, physicians can stop overcommitting by default and start building careers that move forward with clarity and purpose.

Please RATE, REVIEW, and FOLLOW the Medical Mentor Coaching Podcast on your favorite app (Apple Podcasts and Spotify).

If you’d like to connect with us or suggest future topics:

● DM on Instagram at @sishmancoach
● Message us on LinkedIn at Medical Mentor Coaching
● Email [email protected] 
● Visit www.medicalmentorcoaching.com/welcome